I am no apologiser for the RFL/SLE (lets be clear, IMG are their change agents and working to a directive), or equally our own lamentable approach to standards over 25 years - but this is the rub of the argument now.
Is there any point in the 2024 season? If you perform really well, finish 4th with a CC final for example as Cas - but then end up away at Batley for game 1 in 2025 and only find out at the end of the season - that wouldn’t be fair and allow clubs to make good contract decisions when you are relegated with no notice. Impractical already as we will have multi-year contracts in place and so legal challenge is inevitable.
Or, RFL declare the position before the season kicks off, which in essence for some clubs outside the golden 12 means the season is void and you may as well not bother. Another utter folly and if Toulouse and Wakey are in the golden 12, that largely renders the championship season tainted as well.
At best I suspect we can only enforce these gradings in 2025 as a pragmatic view. That doesn’t make them any better as a criteria, but on a practical level in their current form it is a bit of a mess.