Takeover talk

RaoulDuke

There seems to be rumours of a takeover in the offing.

Talk of Paul Caddick and Robert Elstone.

Has anybody heard anything more concrete?

Elstone was in the railway end at start of the Catalans game last week.

mucky1978

Both their yesterday apparently

RaoulDuke

Never seen Caddick there myself bit then I don’t go in the main stand, where is expect him to be smoozed.

The rhinos have just said goodbye to a long time director. So maybe things over there are coming to an end

FlatCapper

The rumour(s) appear to be growing but just like the stadium, I’ll believe it when I see it.

Whatever may be forthcoming, there’s a sizeable loan to the Fulton’s that needs paying off so it may be a case of IF realising the only realistic way to ever achieve payback is to let someone else invest and rebuild the Club.

Here’s hoping so…

Matt

I think it’s clear that Ian Fulton doesn’t want to invest or take the club any further so having some new owners come in if they’re willing to help improve the club both on and off the field can’t be a bad thing.

I said not so long ago that we failed pretty spectacularly when it came to building on the 2017 season. For the first time in probably decades we had players wanting to come and be a part of the culture and team and we really should have taken that moment when it was there.

Just as in any other business the BOD have to take the blame, we failed to bring in a suitable replacement for Powell, allowed multiple retirement fund players to sign for the club and then we gave the head coach role to someone who has pretty much been the under study to Radford.

I’d really like it if someone came in with a proper vision and communicated with the fans on a more regular basis. If we need to make some cuts in order to survive say so, give us a long term vision for the club and what’s actually happening as the way it currently stands we hear nothing.

RL isn’t some cash rich sport and if Ian Fulton is basically holding back the club due to loans he has invested or what ever it might be then alternatives need to be found. Fan confidence is at an all time low, team moral is just as bad and we’re heading down the same path as we did in 2004 - this time though the championship is a lot stronger and there’s no guarantee we’d come straight back up, especially with the whole IMG side of things too.

mdean

Matt Really sensible view Matt, I have said many times leadership is a specific skill and setting out a vision about the club, experience, the planning off the field. Reserves and womens teams and finally the first 13 is vital.

Lets get an identity and something we can get behind for the longer term - because when you’re in this hand to mouth situation, everything feels like a must win and you’re in a binary situation.

It is crystal clear that something has to change I am afraid. I don’t know a lot about the individuals involved so will not indulge in hyperbole.

RaoulDuke

After a good 2017 all of a sudden we have a team with current internationals in it. Gale, mcmeeken, then adz and oggy got a call up. We suddenly have to find more money to keep them which meant we couldn’t recruit properly.

We have to be honest about our clubs limitations and it’s ceiling. I really believe that 2017 was it. We might get to the challenge cup final but the same teams win it each year. Every now and again a team pops up and flukes it.

It’s the same with the league, it’s the same teams but occasionally one gets it right but you either have a strong 1- 17 or a mediocre squad, you can’t have both. Then you need very few injuries. A bit of luck doesn’t go amiss either. Then there’s the things that are out of the ordinary, hardaker comes to mind obviously.

Our aim is to be a regular playoff team that doesn’t flirt with relegation, with the odd cup final and maybe a win every 15 - 20 years. It’s been like that since I started watching Cas in the 70s.

Every club needs an owner with deep pockets because there’s little money to be made if any at all. We aren’t a trophy asset, no team in the sport in the northern hemisphere is.

I don’t believe we could get a regular crowd of 10k so we have to maximise what we have. If we couldn’t do it in 2017, pre Brexit and pandemic, we can’t.

Hepworth

One of the hardest things I’ve found running businesses is attracting new investors,even when the model is profitable. No such sureties in Rugby League,I wouldn’t think any investor savvy enough to make money in the first place would realistically expect a return. Ian Fulton has been roundly criticised for loaning the club money at rates a couple of percent above the banks base rate,truth is if the banks won’t lend you money that’s the price you pay,I have business loans from private investors and everyone is 2% above the base rate. Jack Fultons heart was in Cas, Ian Fulton is first and foremost a businessman his loyalties lay elsewhere. I sincerely hope he’s a good businessman and the current lack of investment and trimming of the squad to reduce the outgoings is an excercise in making investing in the club look more appealing rather than something more sinister.

RaoulDuke

Your very much right. Looking for profit in a sports team is hard but not impossible. The thing is to get in at the right time and out at the right time.

Take Manchester United as an example. The glazers could see that the game was only only to get bigger and that meant more broadcasting money. So they mortgaged old Trafford to buy the club and then used the income to pay the interest. They then bought players with the broadcasting money and pocketed good dividends. They are now selling with the debt still as big as ever and looking at a minimum 3bn profit. They haven’t updated the ground and done minimal to the training ground. They are selling for someone to buy a trophy asset.

Same at Chelsea but the Russian didn’t his own money but his country’s stolen money and if it hasn’t have been for the Ukrainian war he’d have made over a billion.

So which rugby League club is worth something. Well one is Cas but it would be a specific owner. We are building a new ground and so let’s say we get the 12.2m and we’ve still got the 2m council money. If a builder can build it cheaper than 14 2m and so pay the staff is all profit. The bigger the builder, the more savings on buying bulk materials for more than one job, same with machinery and you’ve staff not waiting for the next job on a payroll.

Caddick built headingley up and Yorkshire cricket have a large mortgage on their joint stand. I’m sure the rhinos have their build incorporated into the full cost. So it might make financial sense to a builder

Hepworth

I’m assuming if Wheldon Road is to be redeveloped the work will be put out to tender and the winning builder/developer,who will have their profit margin factored in to the quote will do the job. At this point,business wise,they should saddle up their horse,stick the money in the saddlebag and ride off into the sunset. I think the game as a whole is in trouble,if Saints can win a grand final,and a challenge cup in the same season and see their losses increase,and every Super League team is operating at a loss something has got to give. The sugar daddies are keeping the game afloat,without them we’re stuffed. Investing in a team like Man Utd,turnover circa 640 million,I get,the Glazers first and foremost are shrewd,they financed their way to a small fortune and leave behind a club mired in debt. Would the same model work at Cas,turnover 6 million,loans outstanding….I think not. Sadly investing in Cas would have to be done for love not money. As a business owner would I do it,absolutely not. Personally if I had the liquidity…like a bloody shot lol. And if we were to attempt the Salford model and go for a fan owned entity, I’d be writing a cheque.

Maturecasfan

https://castlefordtigers.com/article.php?id=8615

Hepworth

Maturecasfan
Thanks for posting that I’d missed it. It’s good that statement has been issued and it’s nice to have some clarity especially with regards to other parties interest in the club and the fact that we are still in the market to strengthen the squad.I haven’t always agreed with the board and have been critical of their decision making but no-one should ever stoop to abusing or threatening them.

CurtisTigers

At least we know it’s not a rumour now it’s been confirmed by the club that they’re in discussion with 2 parties. The light at the end of the tunnel is hopefully beginning to flicker.

RaoulDuke

It’s a better statement than the nothing I expected. It doesn’t say much that we didn’t know but like has been said it’s a confirmation of a chance of a buyout.

stuey

Just hope it does not take as long as the promised new stadium to come to fruition.

FlatCapper

Not sure there’s anything of substance in the statement?🤷🏼‍♂️

I accept the reason for letting players leave but it’s only viable if you immediately replace with like-for-like or better. I don’t think we have. Id also like a better explanation for letting QQ go on loan to be cup tied?

On the investment front, they say there’s some interest but also state there has been over the years and nothing came of those. Planning will be crucial for anyone looking to invest.

I’ve also seen the post by Adrian Vowles and whilst I appreciate his feedback on how players feel, the Club also need to realise the fans need support - lets see some positive changes.

Matt

Nothing in that statement really helps ease the frustrations that the fans have.

We’ve released players in order to look at bringing in new faces. That’s great, we need to do something with our squad but does that mean we don’t have anyone lined up and we’ve only just started the process of recruitment or will we have some positive news over the next week?

Our squad is very thin at the moment and we’re releasing players or sending them out on loan without a direct replacement coming straight in to the squad. Tonight alone we’re now missing Milner and Smith, two players who could have been in the squad.

yorky

What i dont get is why milner & smith who can at least run, if it had been massy & griffin at least thats two pldders less?

Maturecasfan

yorky
Baffles me as well Yorky.

Hepworth

While we are engulfed in rumours it would seem the Trinity takeover is proceeding at pace. With heads of terms agreed and due diligence starting they could have new owners in place as soon as July. Even if the new owners hit the ground running it’s probably too late to save their season but all in all secures the club and offers hope for the future,not just for them but for us. It shows their are still people out there prepared to invest and if there is any truth in the takeover rumours at Cas we could still be a viable entity in Super League.

RaoulDuke

Hepworth you wonder why people want to buy these things at the times they do. A wakey fan wouldn’t wait until his team was relegated to want to help. Saving them in the.off season prior would have given them time to build and survive.

My take is that it’s cheaper now as the owners are desperate to get rid and the price will be lower due to their potential relegation. If he gets them promoted, which he should do as there’s no big spenders left in that league, he can get the fans behind them and he becomes a fantastic owner. There might be profit in a sale once promoted.

Looking at the Cas takeover, someone in a Rolls Royce was apparently been given the tour of our stadium yesterday. If that didn’t scare them off then they might be true fans. Here’s hoping!